Global Editions

Superdeep diamonds confirm ancient reservoir as old as the Moon lies deep under Earth’s surface

Diamonds from the Juina area. Credit: Graham Pearson
by TR Pakistan

Scientists have long suspected that an area of the Earth’s mantle, somewhere between the crust and the core, contains a vast reservoir of rock, comparatively undisturbed since the planet’s formation. However, there has been no firm proof if or where it exists. Now an international group of scientists has measured helium isotopes contained in superdeep diamonds brought to the surface by violent volcanic eruptions, to detect the footprints of this ancient reservoir.  Analyses show that gases found in microscopic inclusions in these diamonds come from a stable subterranean reservoir at least as old as the Moon, hidden more than 410 km below sea level in the Earth’s mantle.

This work will be presented to scientists for the first time on Friday, 23rd August at the Goldschmidt conference in Barcelona, Spain after the publication of the paper in the international journal Science on 15 August, 2019.

After the formation of the Earth, violent geological activity and extra-terrestrial impacts disrupted the young planet, meaning that almost nothing of the Earth’s original structure remains. Then in the 1980’s, geochemists noted that in some basalt lavas from particular locations the ratio of helium 3 to helium 4 isotope was higher than expected, mirroring the isotope ratio found in extremely old meteorites which had fallen to Earth. This indicates that the lava had carried the material from some kind of reservoir deep in the Earth, with a composition which hasn’t changed significantly in the last four billion years.

Read more: The Science of Earthquakes

“This pattern has been observed in ‘Ocean Island Basalts’, which are lavas coming to the surface from deep in the Earth, and form islands such as Hawaii and Iceland,” said research leader Dr. Suzette Timmerman from the Australian National University. “The problem is that although these basalts are brought to the surface, we only see a glimpse of their history. We don’t know much about the mantle where their melts came from.”

To address this problem, Timmerman’s team looked at helium isotope ratios in superdeep diamonds. Most diamonds are formed between 150 to 230 km below the Earth’s crust, before being carried to the surface by melts. Very occasionally some ‘superdeep’ diamonds (created between 230 and 800 km below the Earth’s surface) are brought to the surface. These superdeep diamonds are recognisably different from normal diamonds.

Diamonds are the hardest, most indestructible natural substance known, so they form a perfect time capsule that provides us a window into the deep Earth. Researchers were able to extract helium gas from 23 superdeep diamonds from the Juina area of Brazil. These showed the characteristic isotopic composition that scientists would expect from a very ancient reservoir, confirming that the gases are remnants of a time at or even before the Moon and Earth collided. From the geochemistry of the diamonds, it was found that they were formed in an area called the ‘transition zone’, which is between 410 and 660 km below the surface of the Earth. Researchers believe that this unseen reservoir, left over from the Earth’s beginnings, must be in this area or below it.

Read more: 12 Years After the October Earthquake, Is Pakistan Prepared to Handle Another ‘Big One’?

Timmerman said, “Questions remain about the form of this reservoir; is it a large single reservoir, or are there multiple smaller ancient reservoirs? Where exactly is the reservoir? What is the complete chemical composition of this reservoir? But with this work, we are beginning to home in on what is probably the oldest remaining comparatively undisturbed material on Earth.”

“There has been a lot of work focused on identifying the location of primordial reservoirs in the deep Earth. So this is an interesting result, with a lot of potential to “map out” where elevated 3He/4He domains are located in the Earth’s deep interior,” said Professor Matthew Jackson from the University of California, Santa Barbara. “Helium can diffuse rapidly at mantle conditions, so it will be important to evaluate whether the ancient helium signature reflects compositions trapped at diamond-formation depths, or the composition of the host lava that transported to diamonds to the surface. This work is an important step towards understanding these reservoirs, and points the way to further research.”